Mindfulness and  multitasking are 2 different functions of the mind.
Mindfulness is paying attention to yourself and what’s around you, not going through the motions without thinking. When you pay attention, your mind is fully present in what you’re doing.

Multitasking is doing several things at the same time and spreading your attention, but our brain can only focus on one thing at a time. Switching back and forth between tasks takes brain power and wears you out.

But which is better mindfulness or multitasking ?

Key Takeaways

• While multitasking has its place, it often comes at the cost of focus and accuracy.
• For optimal results, consider mindful focusing, where you consciously shift your attention to one task at a time, maximizing your effectiveness.

Life isn’t always easy, and our fast-paced 21st-century world often demands multitasking. We’re bombarded with information (think thousands of daily ads!), and having to make constant decisions wears us down.

Practicing mindfulness, however, requires slowing down and savoring the present moment. This means appreciating our environment and the things around us. But in our rush, like cars on a highway, do we ever really have time to connect with each other?
The constant need to multitask often forces us to limit our mindfulness to specific moments.

Mindfulness vs Multitasking

Scenarios for Mindfulness:

Family and close relationships: Enjoying meals together without distractions, engaging in meaningful conversations, savoring moments of connection.

Vacation and rest: Immersing yourself in nature, practicing relaxation techniques, appreciating quiet moments of reflection.

Hobbies: Engaging fully in activities you enjoy, such as painting, playing music, or reading without multitasking.

Scenarios for Multitasking:

Work: Combining routine tasks with something enjoyable (listening to music/podcasts while exercising, doing chores), or efficiently switching between projects (product support technician, programmer).

Leisure: Listening to audiobooks/music while walking, studying with focus-enhancing music, or catching up on podcasts during commutes.

General: Engaging in conversations while eating, opening multiple documents/websites for research. 

Scenarios for Crucial Focus

Driving: Maintaining undivided attention on the road and surroundings for safety.
This  is the reason all over the world countries passed laws to prohibit texting while driving.

Operating machinery: Dedicating full attention to ensure precision and prevent accidents.

Medical procedures: Surgeons and medical professionals require unwavering focus during their critical tasks.

Remember: If there are harmful consequences of doing multiple tasks simultaneously that is an indicator.
Choose the appropriate approach based on the situation and your personal needs.

Decision making and Multitasking

Decision-making is one of the most critical skills for achieving our goals. However, when we constantly divide our attention, we also divide our mental focus. This fragmentation makes it difficult to dedicate the necessary energy to evaluate facts and analyze options, which leads to poor decisions.

What is the reason? Our brains are simply not wired for true multitasking. Every time we switch tasks, even for a moment, we lose some context and need to re-immerse ourselves upon returning. This constant mental juggling takes a toll on our cognitive resources, leaving us less equipped to make sound judgments.

Studies confirm this limitation, revealing that multitasking is an illusion. We simply switch back and forth between tasks, never truly focusing on more than one at a time.

So, why do we persist in this futile endeavor? Often, it’s due to the pressure of competing deadlines or the desire to avoid tedious tasks. However, the long-term consequences can be costly. Poor decisions can lead to missed opportunities, wasted resources, and even negative impact on personal relationships.

Mindful decision making 

Benefits: Mindful choices avoid impulsive reactions, and lead to calmer, clearer, and more fulfilling results.

Example) Before replying to a heated email, breathe deeply and consider the other’s perspective.
Example) Calmer doctors make better diagnoses, leading to improved patient outcomes.

Steps:

1. Be aware of our thoughts, feelings, biases and assumptions before making the decision.
 “Know thyself”  said Greek philosopher Socrates 2500 years ago.

2. Stay focused in the present and avoid distractions while gathering facts and evaluating alternatives. 

3 Observe your thoughts and feelings without judgment to be able to see the situation clearly.

4. Think critically about the potential outcomes of each alternative and its impact on yourself and others.

5. Choose the path that best aligns with your personal values and long-term goals.

Mindfulness: A Path to Calm and Clarity

Being in the present moment: Pay attention to what’s happening right now, with openness and curiosity.
Observing your breath is a powerful tool for grounding yourself in the present moment.

Observing your thoughts, feelings and sensations: Notice them without getting caught up in them.

Acceptance: Accepting experiences, whether positive or negative, accepting what you can’t control. helps emotional balance.

Being  kind and  compassionate towards oneself and others.

This present-moment awareness leads to several benefits, including reduced stress and enhanced focus.

Multiple Benefits of Mindfulness

Reduces stress and anxiety
When you are stressed, your body releases hormones that make your heart race and your muscles tense.
By being here and now, mindfulness helps you detach from overwhelming thoughts and emotions and  activate your relaxation response which brings calmness.

Enhances focus and concentration
With the practice of being present people can concentrate on a single task without being easily distracted, which is a huge help to improve their productivity.

Creativity and problem-solving skills flourish.
By practicing an open and curious mindset, people approach challenges with fresh perspectives, leading to innovation.

Increased self-awareness.
With mindfulness people get a deeper understanding of their thoughts and emotions, they improve their emotional balance. That helps improve their relationships with others.

Improved physical health.
It has been linked to lower blood pressure, improved immune function, and better sleep.

By cultivating the mind-body connection, mindfulness becomes a holistic tool for enhancing our both mental and physical health. 

Grounding Yourself in the Present Moment: A 5-Minute Mindfulness Practice

(For this practice, find a comfortable place where you can safely close your eyes)

1. Close your eyes  
2. Focus on your breath
3. Notice and feel the sensations on your body by gently slowly scanning your body, sending your awareness from your crown down to your toes
 Feel the coolness of the air on your skin as you inhale, and the warmth of your breath as you exhale.
4. Watch what thoughts are coming to your mind
5. Do this for 5-10 minutes.
6. When you’re ready, gently open your eyes and bring your awareness back to your surroundings. Carry the calmness and focus you cultivated in this practice throughout your day.

(Since 60 percent of brain resources are allocated to processing visual input, closing your eyes immediately starts to collect that energy back )

Problems with Multitasking

Multitasking comes with a price; Here are some statistics:

• 40% drop in productivity: Stanford University research found multitasking can decrease productivity by up to 40%.
• 50% longer task completion time: Researchers at the University of California, Irvine found it takes 50% longer to complete a task while multitasking.
• 50% increase in errors: A study published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology revealed a 50% increase in errors when people multitask.

• Distracted driving is a factor in 9% of fatal crashes in the United States, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).
• In 2021, 3,522 people were killed in distracted driving crashes, an increase of 380 from 2020.

• Distracted driving leads to approximately 280,000 injuries per year in the US alone.
• Texting while driving increases the risk of crashing by 23 times.

Impact on Reaction Time:

• Studies show that reaction time can be slowed by 50% when multitasking while driving.
• This delayed reaction time can be the difference between life and death on the road.

Types of Distractions:

• Cell phone use is the most common form of distracted driving, accounting for 60% of all distracted driving crashes.
• Other distractions include eating, drinking, talking to passengers, and using in-vehicle technologies.

Multitasking at Work

Shallow Expertise
As there is a saying “Jack of all trades, master of none”  when you dabble in many different activities you may not excel at any one of them. While you may have a broad range of knowledge and skills, you may lack the depth of expertise and experience to be considered a true master in this particular field.

Reduced Quality
The quality of work also suffers, since you need to juggle between different tasks you can not give enough attention to go deeper in that task and create more impact.

Wearing multiple hats over long periods of time drains the energy. First it is exciting to be able to respond to multiple demands simultaneously, maybe you feel like a superhero but over time you may affect your problem solving ability, because you do not focus continuously on one specific task.

Some examples where work quality may suffer:

• Chef: Forgets to stir a simmering pot while prepping other dishes, leading to burnt food.
• Programmer: Introduces errors into code while fixing bugs and responding to a phone call simultaneously.
• Student: Retains less information while studying and listening to music due to cognitive overload.
• Doctor: Mistakes critical steps during surgery while multitasking, causing harm to the patient.
• Driver: Reacts slower in an emergency situation on the road due to distractions from phone calls or texting.
• Writer: Produces work with typos and grammatical errors due to rushed editing and multitasking.
• Customer service representative: Provides subpar service and inaccurate information because of doing multiple phone calls and online chats.
• Athlete: Loses focus and precision in training due to distractions from music or social media.
• Artist: Creates less detailed and impactful artwork due to divided attention and rushed execution.
• Student: Get lower grades if  they multitask while studying.

Multitasking and Music
Listening to music is pleasant while working on repetitive tasks (Packing orders, doing laundry, answering emails with standard responses, waiting in line,..)
It can boost the motivation but it still divides the attention.
You can try this to see the effect : while reading a text try to listen to a song that has lyrics.
if the music is classic or relaxing and do not have lyrics it divides less attention .

But for maximum efficiency the best is doing the task in complete silence or white noise.

For better results at work:

  Declutter working space,
 Do deep work
 Ditch distractions.
 Craft calm, focused spaces
 Schedule uninterrupted sprints
 Leverage tech for mindfulness.

Relationships
A typical example of non-mindful multitasked  interaction is  when you are trying to talk to a friend  and that person is distracted by the smartphone or not fully listening.

Long term effects
Multitasking all the time can make you stressed, anxious, and depressed. It can also make it harder to focus, remember things, and sleep well. Thinking about too many things at once can overload your brain and make you feel tired and overwhelmed. Multitasking vs. Focused Attention:

Multitasking   involves attending to several tasks at once, dividing your attention and rapidly shifting between them. It looks efficient, but research says the contrary.

Focused attention, on the other hand, is allocating your full attention to a single task.
This allows for deeper processing, improved information retention, and reduced errors.

Focused attention is the best for efficiency and accuracy.

Alternatives to Multitasking

Frequent multitasking can be detrimental for long-term health.
As the pace of the 21st century techno-world increases, we need to deal with several responsibilities. 

Multitasking can be necessary in certain situations, like managing urgent emails while attending a meeting, but it’s essential to avoid multitasking for core tasks like crafting a critical report, debugging complex code, or preparing an important presentation that requires deep focus.

But this does not mean we should multitask at the task level.
One way of doing this is to practice a balanced approach by incorporating daily mindfulness or meditation techniques.

Dedicate a specific time each day – like  early morning or early evening, after work to disconnect from the outside world and recharge your focus.
Every day whether it is mindfulness or meditation technique set up some special time to withdraw from the outer world to gather your forces.

This daily practice will immediately reset your body, calm your nervous system, and leave you feeling refreshed. Over time, these benefits accumulate, and you’ll find increased calmness becoming your natural state. You may even be surprised by your ability to remain composed in situations that used to trigger frustration.

With sharpened focus, you’ll tackle challenges with greater precision, reduce errors, and activate your creative potential.

Multitasking with Caution: Acceptable Scenarios

Low-risk tasks like Folding laundry, watering plants, or doing dishes are safer and perfect for pairing with music or podcasts.
On the other hand high-risk tasks like driving,  surgery or administering medicine demand undivided focus.

Creative and Brainstorming Tasks:
Activities that benefit from diverse stimuli and free-flowing ideas, such as brainstorming sessions, mind mapping, or generating creative solutions.

Simple and repetitive tasks
Repetitive tasks with minimal cognitive requirements, such as data entry, sorting emails, or filing paperwork.
Tasks that require minimal attention and can be performed automatically, such as walking or listening to music while engaged in another activity.
Tasks that involve waiting or downtime and do not require mental energy , such as waiting for a download or for a meeting to start.

Physical Activities
Doing physical exercise while listening to music  audiobooks or podcasts..
Performing household chores while listening to music or having a conversation.
While physical activities can tolerate some multitasking, mental focus is still crucial for household chores.(e.g., safety precautions, quality of completion)

Safe Multitasking
Prioritize the most important task, allocate specific time slots and silence notifications for a focused multitasking session.
Instead of orchestrating everything at once, break down tasks into smaller chunks and schedule dedicated intervals for each, minimizing distractions in between.

Main Factors about a performing a task

1 Complexity   affects how much mental energy is required for task
2 Total available mental energy at the time of the task , are you tired?
3 Mental state do you have a clear mind, or intoxicated or foggy because of sleeplessness
4 Emotional state  Any Worry anxiety depression?
5 Motivation Do you intend to do the task?
6 Duration of the task How long ?
7 Knowledge about the task (skill level)  Are you beginner or skilled?
8 Tools   Do you have proper tools to do the task?
9 Environment Is there anything in the environment that makes the task more difficult, like noise?

By evaluating these factors we can decide if it is safe to do multitasking

While multitasking , this switching of attention, understanding or remembering the new task,  consumes energy.
Even with just two tasks, our attention can feel fragmented, making it harder to focus on each one effectively, due to rapid switching of tasks.
Multitasking often leads to shallower processing due to divided attention

Mindfulness compared to Multitasking

Mindfulness or multitasking which is better ?

Mindfulness: Low cognitive energy requirement
Multitasking: High cognitive requirement

Mindfulness: Focus is Only on present moment and gentle
Multitasking: Divided between multiple tasks intense focus

Mindfulness: Non-judgmental awareness
Multitasking: May involve judging tasks or priorities

Mindfulness: Acceptance of thoughts and emotions
Multitasking: Attempting to control and manage multiple tasks

Mindfulness:  Reduced stress and anxiety, improved focus, increased self-awareness, enhanced relationships, overall well-being
Multitasking: Increased workload, decreased efficiency, potential for errors, stress, and burnout

Mindfulness:  Activities requiring focus and attention to the present moment (meditation, breathing exercises, mindful movement)
Multitasking:  Simple and repetitive tasks, tasks requiring minimal attention, monitoring tasks

Long-term impact
Mindfulness:  Cultivates a sense of calm, clarity, and inner peace
Multitasking: Can lead to chronic stress, burnout, and decreased cognitive function

Mindfulness is generally a relaxation technique; it is not a counterpart of multitasking.

But we can transform and reduce the cost of multitasking using various elements of mindfulness.

Eisenhower Matrix

The Power of Mindful Single Tasking

Task Prioritization and Mindful Focusing as a solution:
It is more natural to do tasks sequentially.
Instead of doing tasks at the same time or close intervals, allocate enough time to finish big chunks of a task.

STEPS

Preparation:
Prioritize the tasks according to importance:
Identify tasks that are both urgent (demanding immediate attention) and important (contributing to long-term goals).
Tools like the Eisenhower Matrix can help.
Ask yourself “What is the most important task right now?

The Eisenhower Matrix sorts tasks by urgency and importance, helping you focus on urgent and important tasks first, delegate urgent but less important tasks, and schedule or eliminate non-urgent tasks.

Eliminate tasks that are not important
Do not accept unimportant Tasks: Decline tasks that don’t align with your priorities or overwhelm your schedule.

Estimate Time: Be realistic about how long each task will take to avoid overloading yourself.
Allocate time on your schedule.
Utilize to-do lists, calendars, and project management apps to stay organized.

Silence phone, close tabs

Performing the Task
Take a deep Breathe: Inhale  exhale. Calm your mind.
Start with the highest priority task

Focus on that one task exclusively and avoid distractions during the allocated time.

Be aware of our thoughts, feelings, biases and assumptions. 

Every few minutes scan your thoughts and feelings.
If you observe you are getting distracted, losing focus:
(Like social media or email notification,sudden noise, thoughts, sensations, unexpected visitor)
First accept it is ok to lose focus, take a few deep breaths, and gently redirect your attention to the task
Release tension: Notice tightness? Take a deep breath and let go. Stay relaxed.
Label distractions and self-talk:
Example “Hunger thought _ I will address you later,” orr “Work thought – I’ll tackle this after lunch.” 

Mindfulness helps you approach tasks with a calm and clear mind, which helps to analyze information objectively and make better decisions.
Apply critical thinking about the facts and the decisions you make, and evaluate the impact on the environment by looking at holistic view of the situation.

If you feel overwhelmed, Reduce Overwhelm Using 4s Words Framework and slow down.

After the task completion: Be kind to yourself and Celebrate your effort, not perfection.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, mindfulness and multitasking offer two contrasting paths.

While multitasking can feel more productive, research shows cons of mindfulness are scattered focus, burning out under the weight of mounting stress.

In contrast, mindfulness offers a pause, a recharge, and a gateway to deeper focus, creativity, and well-being. Studies have shown that mindfulness fosters improved focus, enhanced creativity, and a deeper sense of well-being. It empowers us to handle challenges with clarity, approach relationships with empathy, and develop self-compassion.

So the decision is yours :
Welcome experimentation and discover what works best for you.
There are scenarios to use mindfulness, mindful single tasking and mindful multitasking.
Try incorporating mindfulness practices like meditation or deep breathing into your day.

The beauty of these practices lies in their cumulative effect. Over time, they build inner peace, reduce stress, and sharpen your focus.
Start your day with 10 minutes of meditation, or sprinkle deep mindful breaths throughout your tasks.
Choose your path, and witness the transformative power of mindful living.

More Articles Like This:

Habits of the Creative Mind
The High Price of Multitasking (12 Important Facts)
Habits of the Creative Mind (31 Practical Examples)
How Does the Brain Play Into Mindset? Rewire Your Brain for Success
Mastering Your Focus: 20 Powerful Strategies to Overcome Distractions